Psychiatrists accepting new patients in Fort Collins

Medical doctors who diagnose and prescribe for mental health in Fort Collins, CO that at least one insurer lists as in-network and accepting new patients — ranked by how confident we are the listing is real.

47accepting new patients
7high confidence
Oct 29, 2026last refreshed

  1. Donald Golen, MD

    High confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna, UnitedHealthcare

    2315 E HARMONY RD # 110, Fort Collins 80528 · +1 more

    Call (970) 482-4373Details

  2. Scott Strader, MD

    High confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna, UnitedHealthcare

    2315 E HARMONY RD # 110, Fort Collins 80528 · +1 more

    Call (970) 482-4373Details

  3. Joseph Gottfried, MD

    High confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    4601 CORBETT DR, Fort Collins 80528

    Call (970) 207-4800Details

  4. Richard Morgan, MD

    High confidence

    Primary care doctor, Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna, UnitedHealthcare

    951 W PLUM ST MOBY ARENA 141, Fort Collins 80523 · +1 more

    Call (970) 419-7050Details

  5. Ali Saad, MD

    High confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna, UnitedHealthcare

    2315 E HARMONY RD # 110, Fort Collins 80528 · +1 more

    Call (970) 482-4373Details

  6. Jennifer Osborne, MD

    High confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    63 N QUEBEC ST # 201, Denver 80230 · +1 more

    Call (719) 540-2146Details

  7. Ryan Barmore, MD

    High confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    702 W DRAKE RD # A, Fort Collins 80526

    Call (970) 810-5612Details

  8. Aj Schuster, MD

    Medium confidence

    Primary care doctor, Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    1025 PENNOCK PL # 121, Fort Collins 80524

    Call (970) 207-4857Details

  9. Andrew Smith, MD

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare

    2315 E Harmony Rd Ste 110, Fort Collins 80528

    Call (970) 482-4373Details

  10. Angel Nickels

    Medium confidence

    Primary care doctor, Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    777 BANNOCK ST, Denver 80204 · +2 more

    Call (303) 602-4357Details

  11. Anita Kumar, MD

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    3351 EASTBROOK DR # 200, Fort Collins 80525

    Call (888) 374-5066Details

  12. Brenda George, DO

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare

    2315 E Harmony Rd Ste 110, Fort Collins 80528

    Call (970) 482-4373Details

  13. Carrie Keffler, MD

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    3351 EASTBROOK DR # 200, Fort Collins 80525

    Call (888) 374-5066Details

  14. Charlece Hughes, DO

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    2315 E HARMONY RD # 110, Fort Collins 80528

    Call (970) 482-4373Details

  15. Charles Haverty, DO

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    2860 S CIRCLE DR # 310, Colorado Springs 80906 · +1 more

    Call (888) 374-5066Details

  16. Colin Carpenter, MD

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare

    3744 S Timberline Rd Ste 102, Fort Collins 80525

    Call (970) 495-0506Details

  17. Elijah Lackey, MD

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare

    2121 E Harmony Rd Unit 180, Fort Collins 80528

    Call (970) 226-6111Details

  18. Erica Kafka, PA-C

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    3351 EASTBROOK DR # 200, Fort Collins 80525

    Call (888) 374-5066Details

  19. George Girardi, MD

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare

    3744 S Timberline Rd Ste 102, Fort Collins 80525

    Call (970) 495-0506Details

  20. Janae Dupuis, MD

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare

    2315 E Harmony Rd Ste 110, Fort Collins 80528

    Call (970) 482-4373Details

  21. Jessica Williams, MD

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare

    2315 E Harmony Rd Ste 110, Fort Collins 80528

    Call (970) 495-7000Details

  22. Keri Lemmond, MD

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    151 W LAKE ST, Fort Collins 80524

    Call (970) 491-7121Details

  23. Kwang-Soo Park, MD

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with Cigna

    3351 EASTBROOK DR # 200, Fort Collins 80525

    Call (719) 394-3352Details

  24. Matthew Pouliot, DO

    Medium confidence

    Primary care doctor, Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare

    3744 S Timberline Rd Ste 102, Fort Collins 80525

    Call (970) 495-0506Details

  25. Michael Brown, DO

    Medium confidence

    Psychiatrist

    Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare

    3744 S Timberline Rd Ste 102, Fort Collins 80525

    Call (970) 495-0506Details

At a glance

Computed from insurer directories and the NPI registry on Oct 29, 2026.

Psychiatrists by insurance

Before you call

Common questions

Are these psychiatrists really accepting new patients?

Each one is marked as accepting new patients in at least one insurer's official directory. Because those directories are often wrong, we score each listing using cross-checks against the federal NPI registry, so you can call the most reliable ones first.

What should I say when I call?

Give your insurer and plan name, ask whether they're in-network for that specific plan, whether they're accepting new patients, and how long the wait is for a first appointment. Each profile has a copy-paste script.