Psychiatrists accepting new patients in Colorado Springs
Medical doctors who diagnose and prescribe for mental health in Colorado Springs, CO that at least one insurer lists as in-network and accepting new patients — ranked by how confident we are the listing is real.
-
Charles Nielsen, DO
High confidencePrimary care doctor, Psychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna, UnitedHealthcare
320 E FONTANERO ST # 100, Colorado Springs 80907 · +2 more
-
Brandon Baker, DO
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
9475 BRIAR VILLAGE PT # 320, Colorado Springs 80920
-
Linda Bucher, NP-C
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
4090 BRIARGATE PKWY, Colorado Springs 80920
-
Matthew Mills, DO
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
6071 E WOODMEN RD # 200, Colorado Springs 80923
-
Megan Whitehead, FNP
High confidencePrimary care doctor, Psychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna, UnitedHealthcare
9925 FEDERAL DR # 110, Colorado Springs 80921 · +1 more
-
Pankaj Nashikkar, MD
High confidencePrimary care doctor, Psychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna, UnitedHealthcare
2920 N CASCADE AVE # 201, Colorado Springs 80907 · +1 more
-
Aaron Avallone
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
2860 S CIRCLE DR # 310, Colorado Springs 80906
-
Ashley Mcdonnell, FNP
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
2222 N NEVADA AVE # 4007, NH, Colorado Springs 80907
-
Daniel Johnson, PA
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
875 W MORENO AVE, Colorado Springs 80905 · +1 more
-
Deepika Patel, PSYD
High confidencePsychiatrist, Psychologist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
2375 TELSTAR DR # 160, Colorado Springs 80920
-
Diane Hesselbrock, MD
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
4110 BRIARGATE PKWY # 405, Colorado Springs 80920
-
Eva Kolb, DO
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
6208 LEHMAN DR, Colorado Springs 80918 · +5 more
-
Finis Taylor, DO
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
6071 E WOODMEN RD # 200, Colorado Springs 80923 · +1 more
-
Grayson Sanders, PA-C
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
6566 N MARKSHEFFEL RD # 100, Colorado Springs 80923
-
Ian Peters, MPH, DO
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
179 S PARKSIDE DR, Colorado Springs 80910
-
Kristina Kurtz, DO
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
5353 N UNION BLVD # 202, Colorado Springs 80918
-
Meghan Comer, FNP
High confidencePrimary care doctor, Psychiatrist · Telehealth
Accepting new patients with Cigna, UnitedHealthcare
6001 E WOODMEN RD, Colorado Springs 80923 · +3 more
-
Richard Chough
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
5725 MARK DABLING BLVD, Colorado Springs 80919
-
Sandra Fritsch, MD
High confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
4090 BRIARGATE PKWY, Colorado Springs 80920
-
Andrea Manhart, D O,
Medium confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare
4110 Briargate Pkwy Ste 140, Colorado Springs 80920 · +1 more
-
Aparna Komatineni, MD
Medium confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare
3920 N Union Blvd Ste 150, Colorado Springs 80907
-
Bradford Witman, PA-C
Medium confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
9362 GRAND CORDERA PKWY # 100, Colorado Springs 80924
-
Brandon Glover, DO
Medium confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with UnitedHealthcare
4110 Briargate Pkwy Ste 140, Colorado Springs 80920
-
Briana Tillman, DO
Medium confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
2860 S CIRCLE DR # 310, Colorado Springs 80906 · +1 more
-
Caleb Jordan
Medium confidencePsychiatrist
Accepting new patients with Cigna
5446 N ACADEMY BLVD # 102, Colorado Springs 80918
No matches on this page. Clear a filter or try the next page.
At a glance
- 19 of 100 (19%) pass enough cross-checks for high confidence — call these first.
- 43% had their insurer record refreshed in the last 90 days.
- 4 list a telehealth or virtual-visit location.
- 44 are women and 56 are men, per the federal NPI registry.
- Accepting by insurer: Cigna 52, Humana 0, UnitedHealthcare 54. 6 are listed as accepting by more than one insurer.
- Most listings by ZIP: 80920 (31), 80907 (18), 80923 (12), 80921 (8), 80906 (8), 80919 (8).
Computed from insurer directories and the NPI registry on Oct 29, 2026.
Psychiatrists by insurance
- Psychiatrists that take Cigna 52 accepting
- Psychiatrists that take UnitedHealthcare 54 accepting
Before you call
Common questions
Are these psychiatrists really accepting new patients?
Each one is marked as accepting new patients in at least one insurer's official directory. Because those directories are often wrong, we score each listing using cross-checks against the federal NPI registry, so you can call the most reliable ones first.
What should I say when I call?
Give your insurer and plan name, ask whether they're in-network for that specific plan, whether they're accepting new patients, and how long the wait is for a first appointment. Each profile has a copy-paste script.